My Take on Comerica Park and Progressive Field

Been a while since my last update on here, but I did end up getting to my ballparks this year of Texas, Detroit, and Cleveland. I loved Rangers Ballpark in Arlington and rank it high on my list. Now I went to Comerica 6 years ago but a lot has changed with that park and Progressive Field, which I have heard mixed reviews on, even by my friends who went to that park.

I'll start with Comerica Park. I am probably biased since I'm a diehard Tigers fan. But I thought the stadium was great, even since the last time I was there. I still miss my Tiger Stadium and cannot see any pictures of the demolition anymore (like watching a person dying to me). But Comerica is more than serviceable. It is a gem of a ballpark and one of the things that is trying to make Detroit a tourist attraction (har har) but it is good. It still ranks as one of the best parks I've been to.

1. The interior-just a scenic backdrop as well as the fountains out in CF.
2. The exterior-great brick facade and the mural of the classic glove behind the LF scoreboard make me think Ty Cobb. That and all the statue of Tigers everywhere
3. The fans-why I am biased. I think Detroit has some of the best fans around.
4. The concourses-reasonably spaced and plenty of spots to stop as well as the food court with the carousel over there.
5. The food-spiciest Italian sausage I ever had. And it was good!
6. Fun things to do-Carousel, Merry-Go-Round, stuff for kids and fans alike.

1. Location-granted, it is Detroit and better than where Tiger Stadium was, but you move past the side where third base is and the area gets dirty quickly. Some other spots were dirty as well.
2. Music-You'd think they had some musice with a Motown beat to it. Nope.
3. Scoreboard-Not bad, but out of date with all the HD boards up in other parks.
4. Souvenir prices-It is a stadium so it is high, but it is a little higher than normal I think.

As for Progressive Field, I was more than pleasantly surprised. It is a beautiful ballpark and it bucked the major trend when the new modern stadiums were built of having brick facades everywhere. Cleveland was the first to really use the exposed steel beams instead of bricks (some spots had bricks, but even then it had an Ohio feel to it, similar to Cincinnati). The inside view was tremendous and beautiful as well. I always thought Cleveland had that poster boy label of how the rest of the teams should build a park (luxury boxes, major souvenir shops, etc.) and throw the "we need a new park to compete" bit. Which might be true considering a lot of teams followed suit but failed to actually put a competing team on the field. That being said, it is a great stadium and it would have been nice to have seen a game in Cleveland's heyday in the 90's. Since then, the fans have stopped coming. It is sad, because even when the Indians have fielded a good team in this decade, fans have stopped coming.

1. Interior-looks neat and clean
2. Exterior-Exposed steel is different than the norm and I like that. Shows character
3. Music-played a few of the songs as well as the theme from "Major League." That and they played rock.
4. 7th inning stretch-had two fans sing the anthem and then played "Hey Sloopy" while the crowd sang to it.

1. Fans-14,000 showed up and of those, 9,000 were Mets fans? I'm beginning to think Municipal Stadium wasn't the reason in having fans not coming out. And the Indians fans who did show up, while nice, were just quiet.

Overall, I would say Comerica still ranks second behind Camden Yards but I would put Progressive Field in third on my personal stadium rankings.

So my top 5 are:
1. Oriole Park at Camden Yards
2. Comerica Park
3. Progressive Field
4. Great American Ballpark
5. Rangers Ballpark in Arlington

Bottom 5:
1. Fulton County Stadium
2. Yankee Stadium
3. Metrodome
4. RFK Stadium
5. Shea Stadium

Unless I hit the lottery and/or win a contest for all-expenses paid for trip to another MLB park this year, my Ballpark Chasing for 2010 is finished. I am heading to Chattanooga for a Lookouts game in one month. Next year will be a tricky one for me to get to another MLB ballpark. Wife and I are talking about kid #2 and she wants it by the summer, meaning no summer trip. However, I have convinced her twice about a trip during spring break (both of us are teachers). If that is the case, we're either going to Arizona, Milwaukee, or Seattle.

Views: 829


You need to be a member of Ballpark Chasers to add comments!

Join Ballpark Chasers

Comment by Kurt Smith on February 15, 2011 at 6:38am
Figured as much. The new one's awesome. Not my favorite but definitely top ten, and it's probably the most majestic, for lack of a better word. I wasn't all that crazy about the old one either, except for the historic aspect of it.
Comment by Tim on February 14, 2011 at 4:51pm
It is the old Yankee Stadium.  I appreciate the history they have at the old place, but besides the history and monument park, I really didn't care for it.
Comment by Kurt Smith on February 13, 2011 at 3:35pm

I love Comerica, one of my favorites. Love the tiger statues at the game, I think that's awesome, and pictures don't even come close to doing it justice.


Is that the "new" Yankee Stadium ranked so low on your list there Tim?

Comment by Tim on July 1, 2010 at 6:13am
Chuck, that is a great story. I actually remember that game you went to.
Meg, thanks! Can't wait to go.
Comment by meg minard (30/44/205) on June 30, 2010 at 8:58pm
I haven’t been to Comerica Park (it’s on my list of stadiums to visit).

I don’t really ‘rank’ ballpark stadiums but, if I did that, Progressive Field would be high on the list (maybe #2 or #3 of the stadiums I’ve seen)
I quite enjoyed strolling through Heritage Park when I was there and seeing/reading the history of baseball in Cleveland

The very best to your growing family.

Enjoy BellSouth Park – I remember enjoying my visit there.
Comment by Chuck Booth (35) ALL 30/23 DAYS! on June 28, 2010 at 10:16pm
I really liked the BALLPARK IN ARLINGTON too--it was the last stadium I went to--the bullpen's are so close you think you are in a minor league park---they just need more scoreboards. Detroit--I agree has some pretty incredible fans. There is lots of stuff interactive at the ballpark that makes it nice. Also at night-with all of their NEON signs it very cool for pictures--I miss the cars in the outfield---but love the TIGERS on the scoreboard. Funny enough I ended my world record chase their last year on a 1-0 p inning game with brandon inge going deep--what an electric atmosphere---and FRIDAY NIGHT fireworks are something else there. There is a street near Chelios's bar where you can park for free--1/2 mile from the yard...
Comment by Tim on June 25, 2010 at 8:21am
I am hoping to get to Milwaukee next year....looks like a great park!
Comment by Nema Brewer-Candy on June 25, 2010 at 7:01am
Thanks for the information! Haven't been to either of these parks yet, but we've been tossing around the idea of making a quick trip to Cleveland or Detroit this summer. We just got back from Milwaukee and it was a blast.


© 2024   Created by Ballpark Chasers   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service